The diarrhea dilemma in puppies often dominates discussions among pet owners, dog breeders, and animal shelters alike. It’s a prevalent concern, with studies highlighting that around 25% of puppies face this issue during the nutritional weaning phase. This is why I have been writing so much about this! And my continuous exploration into this topic has led me to a common household remedy touted for its effectiveness: pumpkin.
Praised across numerous blogs as a near-magical solution for puppies’ digestive woes, it sparked my curiosity about the science behind it. Because determining the amount of pumpkin to give a puppy for diarrhea isn’t the only question one should consider; in my opinion, the real key here is to understand the intricate balance between health and canine nutrition. So in this blog, I deep-dive into the biochemistry of pumpkin as a remedy, aiming to provide you with a scientifically-backed guide on its use… and in the end, if this is something truly worth considering!
- Why Consider Pumpkin for Puppy Diarrhea?
- How Much Pumpkin (Fiber) Should I Give My Puppy for Diarrhea?
- Alternatives to Pumpkin for Diarrhea
Why Consider Pumpkin for Puppy Diarrhea?
Nutritional Benefits of Pumpkin
When it comes to nutrition, it’s essential to see beyond the ingredient itself and concentrate on its nutrient composition—the blend of vitamins, minerals, and fibers it contributes, rather than its mere identity so to speak.
Simply put, while an ingredient is what we add to our diets, its nutrient composition represents the actual substances our bodies utilize for energy, growth, and repair.
This approach aligns with “nutritional biochemistry,” a fascinating concept I discovered recently in my readings that explores the interaction between the nutrients in our food and our bodies at a molecular level – and how nutrition influences our health and well-being.
So, when considering adding something like pumpkin to a diet, it’s not merely about the pumpkin; it’s about acknowledging the specific nutrients it provides and how they can benefit our puppies.
Indeed, pumpkin is often celebrated for its rich nutritional profile.
This vegetable is packed with essential vitamins and minerals, notably Vitamin A, potassium, and iron, which support vision, muscle health, and overall vitality.
Additionally, pumpkin is a low-calorie option teeming with fiber, which aids in digestive health.
But wait… FIBER: here is the keyword you MUST remember here when it comes to its digestive benefits!
Fibers are natural substances found in plants that our bodies can’t digest, they are kind of the superheroes of the digestive world, acting like a cleanup crew that helps keep your stomach and intestines healthy and running smoothly.
Yet, the story of fiber is more nuanced than it appears – it’s a nutrient rich in complexity, with two key types to understand.
Pumpkin shines as a prime example, boasting both soluble and insoluble fibers, each playing a pivotal role in enhancing digestive wellness.
Puzzled by the terms soluble and insoluble? You are not the only one – keep reading!
How Pumpkin (Fiber) Helps With Diarrhea
Soluble fiber is like a sponge in your gut; it absorbs water and turns into a gel during digestion, helping to slow down how fast food moves through your system.
They are found in foods like oats, peas, beans, apples, and citrus fruits. This type can help lower cholesterol and control blood sugar levels. Imagine it as the ingredient that thickens your smoothie!
Insoluble fiber, on the other hand, is the roughage in your diet.
They are found in foods like whole wheat flour, wheat bran, nuts, beans, and vegetables, such as cauliflower, green beans, and potatoes. Think of it as a broom for your digestive tract, sweeping through and helping to keep things moving. It doesn’t dissolve in water, so it adds bulk to your stool and helps prevent constipation. It’s what gives vegetables their crunch!
And pumpkin is an excellent source of both, making it a versatile component in promoting digestive health.
The unique combination of these fibers not only supports a healthy digestive tract but also contributes to overall gut health by encouraging beneficial gut bacteria growth, explaining why it is often considered as a dietary addition for puppies experiencing digestive issues.
The following table is adapted from a webinar I recently watched and summarizes what to expect from the different types of fibers:
-Regulation of microbiome: Adjusting the balance of bacteria in the gut for better health.
– Energy supply for the microbiome: Providing food for gut bacteria to produce energy.
– Promotion of bacterial growth: Encouraging the increase of beneficial bacteria in the gut.
– Regulation of intestinal motility: Helping the digestive system move food through the gut more smoothly.
– Fecal cosmetics: Improving the appearance, consistency, and health of stool.
I am on a mission to learn everything about dog and cat breeding. Sign up to my newsletter to follow my journey, and receive exclusive content and offers!
Safe for Puppies?
The one thing I want you to remember here: fibers play a vital role in maintaining the digestive health of puppies.
They act as a natural regulator that ensures smooth and regular bowel movements… while ALSO supporting the puppy’s gut microbiome (and as I wrote earlier, this one is now considered by many as a crucial organ in a developing puppy!).
Their importance transcends the type of food they come from, as they help to prevent issues like diarrhea and constipation, keeping your puppy happy and healthy.
The focus therefore should never be on “pumpkin”; it should really be on ensuring your puppy gets an adequate amount of fibers overall, regardless of the source picked.
And actually… “pumpkin” might not always be safe for your puppies!
Because it comes in many different forms – and some are definitely to be avoided.
See the table below to understand what I mean here!
| Commercial Pumpkin Form | Nutritional Composition | OK for Puppies? |
| Fresh Pumpkin | High in vitamins (especially Vitamin A), minerals, and fibers. Low in calories. | Yes |
| Canned Pure Pumpkin | Similar to fresh, but may contain added water or salt. Look for no-salt-added varieties to ensure purity. | Yes, with caution |
| Pumpkin Supplement Powder | Concentrated source of fiber and nutrients, varying by brand. Check for added ingredients. | Yes, with caution |
| Pumpkin Pie Spice | Not actually pumpkin but a blend of spices often used in pumpkin pie. It often contains Xylitol, which is an artificial sweetener included in some blends that is toxic to dogs. | No |
How Much Pumpkin (Fiber) Should I Give My Puppy for Diarrhea?
Determining the Right Amount
In my lectures, I often emphasize that understanding nutrition involves answering three fundamental questions: what you feed, how you feed it, and how much you feed it.
This framework is also crucial when considering the role of fiber in a dog’s diet for optimal digestive health.
And let’s go back to “pumpkin” for a second.
The Merck Veterinary Manual suggests pet owners can incorporate 1–4 tablespoons of pumpkin per meal into their dog’s diet to enhance digestive health—a piece of advice widely echoed across numerous blogs.
However, this recommendation doesn’t fully capture the complete narrative.
The exact sentence is the following: “The pet owner may add […] pumpkin (1–4 tbsp/meal) to canned food”.
This last part is crucial as typically, canned dog food contains a lower fiber content compared to dry dog food.
Side note: the mentioned guidance comes from an article addressing constipation management in dogs, and is not directly applicable to diarrhea. Yet, considering pumpkin’s composition of both soluble and insoluble fibers, we can anticipate benefits for both conditions.
I’ve noticed that fibers are frequently recommended for improving “fecal cosmetics” in dogs, a term which simply means… enhancing the aspect/look and consistency of their stools.
And this consideration is particularly relevant in mild cases of diarrhea, which, interestingly, account for 84% of diarrhea cases observed in veterinary clinics.
Mild diarrhea refers to slight changes in stool consistency without severe symptoms like dehydration or weight loss. In these instances, incorporating fibers into a dog’s diet can be beneficial, but if you’re unsure, consulting with your veterinarian is always the best course of action.
A common guideline I came across suggests providing a dog with 0.5-1g of fiber per kg of body weight per day to aid for this “fecal cosmetics” thing.
This is where the fascinating part comes in: it was mentioned that to obtain 20g (so what would be recommended for a 22kg – 44lb dog) of fiber from canned pumpkin, a dog would need to consume about… 3 cups of it.
Personally, I prefer the precision of grams over the use of “cups” as a measurement unit (probably the European side of me). Because 3 cups of canned pumpkin… well I have a hard time realizing what it actually represents in terms of food quantity.
I did the conversion for this blog: 3 cups is roughly equivalent to a substantial… 711 grams – a quantity that could pose challenges as one might expect.
Just so you know, the daily recommended amount of dry food for an adult dog weighing 20 kg (about 44 lbs) is approximately 200-300 grams… Huge difference here!
While the fibers in pumpkin are beneficial for digestive health, they are certainly not a cure-all, and the practicality of using canned pumpkin, especially in the quantities required for puppies, may not be the most feasible option in my view!
Precautions and Considerations
The incorporation of fiber supplements like pumpkin into a puppy’s diet undeniably offers significant digestive advantages, yet this discussion serves as a critical reminder of an overarching principle: the essence of nutrition lies in balance, and this holds true for fiber supplementation as well.
Administering the appropriate amount is paramount; an excess can indeed lead to unintended consequences.
A study on working dogs highlighted a notable drawback of over-supplementing fiber: a reduction in food’s palatability, which refers to its appeal and taste to the dog.
This decline in palatability can severely restrict a puppy’s consumption of other essential nutrients, particularly detrimental during their vital growth phase.
Echoing these sentiments, the webinar I previously referenced illuminated the risks of excessive fiber intake, such as softer stools, altered stool consistency – and an increase in stool bulk (which we should not forget means more work for the ones cleaning up after the puppy…).
These changes underscore the delicate dance of dietary management, emphasizing that while fiber is beneficial, an overabundance can disrupt the nutritional harmony essential for a puppy’s health and development.
The way I see it, it’s a potent reminder that when it comes to fiber, as with all aspects of nutrition, moderation is key.
Alternatives to Pumpkin for Diarrhea
As you might have understood by now, pumpkin is not my preferred method for incorporating fibers into a puppy’s diet to aid digestive health.
I’ve detailed my approach to managing diarrhea in puppies in a previous blog post. I encourage you to explore it for a more comprehensive understanding. In the following, however, I will exclusively concentrate on alternative sources of fiber.
Start with an adapted puppy dry diet
To optimize digestive health in puppies, my primary recommendation is always to begin… with a balanced dry diet, specifically one that’s been optimized for digestive health.
Check the claims made on the packaging. This is where you’ll find invaluable insights into the diet’s benefits, offering far more useful information than the ingredient deck alone, which scarcely scratches the surface of the nutritional composition.
These diets are typically characterized by their high digestibility—a critical factor in ensuring that puppies can efficiently absorb the nutrients they need.
So before adding a myriad of supplements (including pumpkin…), simply transitioning to a puppy diet that promotes digestive health can make a significant difference for sure.
Here are some of the nutrients I prioritize when selecting a puppy food designed to promote optimal digestive health:
| Nutrient | Benefit for Digestive Health |
| Highly Digestible Proteins | Easier for puppies to break down and absorb, reducing the risk of stomach upset. |
| FOS (Fructooligosaccharides) | Acts as a prebiotic, stimulating the growth of beneficial bacteria in the colon. |
| MOS (Mannan-oligosaccharides) | Helps block pathogenic bacteria from adhering to the intestinal walls, supporting a healthy gut flora. |
| Betaglucans | Supports the immune system and helps maintain a healthy gut barrier. |
| Sugar Beet Pulp | A source of soluble and insoluble fiber that aids in regular bowel movements and supports a healthy gut. |
| Psyllium | Absorbs water to help regulate bowel movements, making it beneficial for both constipation and diarrhea. |
A key component of these specialized diets is the inclusion of prebiotics.
Prebiotics are nutrients that promote the growth of beneficial bacteria within the digestive system. The most well-known are named FOS (Fructo-Oligo-Saccharide) and MOS (Mannan-Oligo-Saccharide), and those are (guess what?)… fibers!
This is crucial because, during puppyhood, the microbiome—the community of microbes living in the digestive tract—is still maturing. It plays a pivotal role in the digestive process, and supporting this development by “feeding” the good bacteria with prebiotics is essential for optimal digestive health.
Once again, it’s also vital to remember that the application of these diets is just as important as their content.
Proper usage, especially during critical periods like weaning, can significantly impact a puppy’s health.
For instance, distributing the diet across four meals a day has been shown to enhance stool quality and consistency in puppies, demonstrating the profound effect feeding practices can have.
Additionally, these diets always contain fiber, with ratios tailored (ideally) to the size of the puppy, acknowledging that digestibility can vary significantly based on the anticipated adult size of the dog.
This tailored approach ensures that each puppy receives precisely what it needs for optimal growth and health.
Psyllium, cellulose, FOS, MOS
Sometimes, veterinarians may recommend the use of fiber supplements in puppies, depending on the situation, so it’s essential to consult with your attending veterinarian first to ensure they are used properly and efficiently.
Keep in mind that in severe diarrhea cases, fiber supplementation alone is never sufficient; these approaches are typically reserved for the mild diarrhea cases I mentioned earlier.
In veterinary circles, when it comes to fiber supplements, psyllium and cellulose are the two most commonly mentioned. (No mention of pumpkin in most of the seminars I attended…)
Psyllium is a type of soluble fiber sourced from the husks of the Plantago ovata plant’s seeds.
It’s known for its ability to absorb water, making it beneficial in forming bulkier, softer stools that are easier to pass.
On the other hand, cellulose is an insoluble fiber found in the cell walls of plants. It aids in the movement of food through the digestive system and is instrumental in maintaining bowel health.
To put the effectiveness of these supplements into perspective, consider the requirement of 711 grams of canned pumpkin to provide 20 grams of fiber.
In stark contrast, only 2 tablespoons of psyllium are needed to achieve the same amount of fiber, making it a highly efficient option worth considering in certain cases.
If you remember the table I shared in the previous paragraph, it is good to keep in mind that some puppy diets are already enhanced with psyllium, aligning with my preference for choosing nutritionally complete options that negate the need for additional supplementation.
Another fiber supplement that is often mentioned in puppies and in dogs: FOS and MOS.
FOS (Fructooligosaccharides) acts as a prebiotic, stimulating the growth of beneficial bacteria, while MOS (Mannan-oligosaccharides) helps prevent the adhesion of harmful bacteria to the gut walls, supporting overall intestinal health.
As highlighted in my earlier table, some puppy diets are already enriched with these nutrients, making them my preferred choice.
Including FOS and MOS directly within a balanced diet ensures puppies receive these benefits seamlessly, emphasizing the importance of selecting a diet that supports digestive health comprehensively.
This integration ensures that puppies not only receive the right amount of fiber but also benefit from a diet tailored to support their overall digestive health from the outset.
See the table below re: Fiber type to consider according to symptoms and desired effects
| Symptoms and desired effects | Fiber type to consider |
| Fecal cosmetics | Cellulose |
| Support of the intestinal flora | FOS, MOS |
| Mucosal Damage | Psyllium |
| Satiety | Psyllium, Cellulose |
A Gastro-Intestinal Therapeutic diet?
Numerous studies underscore the efficacy of fibers in addressing diarrhea in dogs, with an increasing body of evidence now positioning fiber-supplemented diets—or high-fiber diets—as the primary treatment for the vast majority of diarrhea cases, especially chronic diarrhea cases.
I find the term “chronic diarrhea” itself to be intriguing, generally defined as diarrhea persisting for more than three weeks.
This is something described in puppies, and you need to be aware that interpretations vary, with some experts suggesting that even intermittent episodes of diarrhea could be classified as chronic.
This highlights the complexity of the condition and the importance of the therapeutic approach here.
It is mentioned that 50-60% of dogs suffering from chronic diarrhea will respond to nutritional dietary intervention.
The consensus emphasizes the strategic incorporation of both soluble and insoluble fibers into the diet, leveraging their combined benefits for digestive health.
This evolution in dietary strategy marks a significant advancement in veterinary medicine. In the past, the default response to such cases often involved administering antibiotics—a practice I, too, engaged in early in my career, simply because there was a lack of alternative knowledge at the time.
Today, we understand that indiscriminate antibiotic use can profoundly disrupt the delicate balance of the digestive microbiome. This is particularly consequential for growing puppies, where such disruptions during a critical period of microbiome and gastrointestinal development may predispose them to chronic gastrointestinal issues later in life.
Engaging in a dialogue with your veterinarian about these dietary strategies can be a crucial step in navigating the complexities of digestive health issues, underscoring the shift towards more holistic and informed approaches in veterinary care.
And yes – some of those diets are specifically tailored to puppies, meaning they not only bring those digestive health benefits but also cover the nutritional needs related to their growth as well.
As this exploration reveals, while I’m not particularly keen on adding pumpkin to puppies’ diets for diarrhea, it’s been insightful to delve into the nutritional science behind this choice. The benefits are tangible, yet so are the limitations. Focusing on “Fiber” is definitely more important than focusing on “Pumpkin” in my opinion. And fiber emerges as a complex yet potent nutrient, illustrating why many veterinarians now opt for fiber supplements over antibiotics for mild diarrhea cases—clearly, our understanding has evolved. This blog barely scratches the surface of fiber’s intricacies, yet it’s evident that thoughtful nutrition can work wonders in managing puppy health. So should any doubts arise, engaging in a conversation with your veterinarian on this topic can provide clarity and direction, ensuring the well-being of your furry companion.
One of the most common challenge we encounter in breeding kennels is NEONATAL MORTALITY.
It can be very frustrating… even heart-breaking.
Good news though : you can do something about it !
We now have more knowledge than ever in this discipline.
In recent years, new research brought us a much better understanding of what can be done to optimize the health of newborn puppies.
By taking this course, this is what you will learn indeed !
DR. EMMANUEL FONTAINE 